My Social Media timelines are full of people arguing, ranting, discussing the proposed benefits cuts and the Green Paper which was put forward in parliament on Monday 17th March by The Secretary for State and Pensions, Liz Kendall.
I keep commenting and deleting because I have so much to say, but the vitriol is rife and I just can’t deal with it. So I decided to put my thoughts forward here because this is my place and I can say what I really feel.
Pathways to Work: Reforming Benefits and Support to Get Britain Working
The Green Paper
I’ve read the green paper, all 84 pages of it, even though a lot of it doesn’t have any affect on me. The first reading makes you think there are some interesting ideas. Yes, there are too many unemployed and the number is rising. Yes, people are better off working. Yes, people need more help to get back into work.
The first thing you are hit with are the figures. Over 9 million people out of work, over 2 million on sickness benefits.
Then the dates, the increase happened around 2020 which we all know as Covid year. I don’t think the effects of Covid on so many people has been properly addressed. People who nearly died, people who suffered losses of family members, people who lost their jobs and have been unable to find other employment. None of this has been observed or assisted.
I have three children who suffered during Covid, one lost her GCSE years, one suffered from education for years after being unable to fit in to school but he’s doing okay now, because I fought for help. The other caught Covid and was really poorly and her health has suffered ever since. Has this been addressed? No, because we keep getting pushed back, these things are hard to diagnose.
I mention this for two reasons. One is because I have experienced the effects that Covid has had on young lives. Those who are now trying to fit in and get work or continue their further education. These are the people being ‘attacked’ in the green paper. Basically being told to pull themselves together and go out there and get a job or live on fresh air. But, I’m pretty sure they would like to but they need help and there is so little help available.
Putting the health and care system back on its feet, tackling the
unacceptably high waiting times with almost £26 billion of extra funding
so people get the treatment they need to get back to health and back to
work.
Apparently this has been in place since last year. With a young person looking for help I can honestly say I’ve not seen it in action. Getting help is practically impossible, believe me I’ve tried and tried, so many different places. Where is this help?
So, I truly welcome any help for young people to get to work. And I hope it will happen. My daughter will be happy to take it up, but as someone who is not in education (not because of not trying) she cannot even gain access to any help until she is 18. So, we wait. She gets NO money, no benefits. And I get no child benefit and no top up on my benefits for her. Because her college let her go because she wasn’t doing well enough in her courses. ( Twice) Did the college try to help her? That’s a whole other story, but the short answer is no. Nobody wants to employ a 17 yr old with health issues and no education. Fingers crossed when she reaches 18 she will get help.
Health Benefits
This is the issue I wanted to talk about most though.
The green paper says that people with mental health issues would be better off in work. I agree, I totally loved working, interacting with my work colleagues, getting up every day and having a purpose in life. And the money was okay sometimes too (I’ve had many different jobs working on the lowest rates and pretty high rates of pay.) The problem is defining mental health.
The green paper seems to put it all under one big umbrella and that is not the case. We need to start from the very beginning.
We need to get these people properly assessed. It’s easy to go to the GP and say I’m feeling depressed, get some pills and then sign off work because you are mentally unwell. But, in most cases you should be well again in a few months and ready for work again.
On the other hand there are people with genuine mental health issues where getting out of bed, getting washed, brushing your teeth and even opening the curtains to a new day seem like the biggest task in the world. What help do they get? I will be frank with you here. I told my GP I had attempted suicide, something I feel deep shame about, but I was feeling the lowest of low and my mind wasn’t working properly. I’ve also researched which of my medication could kill me the quickest and easiest. (my attempt was way off, if I’d chosen one of other pills I’d have only had to take 10 to cause a coma, 20 and I wouldn’t have woken. I didn’t know this until researching it. That action alone proves that I needed help.) I told this to my mental health assessor and they put me forward for nine different pathways to help for my needs. In the past two years I have received two of those pathways (online and by telephone) I’ve not received one single face to face help. I have learnt to help myself. I actually have certificates in courses for Cognitive behavioural Therapy (CBT) and Dialectical Behavioural Therapy (DBT) so I have all the tools to hand. I have three mental health apps. on my phone. I am able to do this, many people with mental health conditions do not.
You cannot make someone go to work and suddenly get rid of all their problems. Get them proper assessments and if they need more help give it to them. If they don’t then get them into a job that will support them and they will thrive. I have a family member with severe mental health problems and yet they work, because they have the right help and support. It is possible.
Personal Independence Payment
There are many benefits available to people with health issues and some of them are pretty easy to get and definitely need some kind of reform. I don’t have time to go into them and they don’t affect me so I don’t feel qualified enough to write about them. But there is one benefit that I would like to talk about and that is Personal Independence Payment or PIP as it is known.
PIP is given to disabled people to help with them live with independence. Being disabled is costly. I get my medications for free on the NHS (For now) but I have to pay for all of my aids and trust me it’s not cheap.
PIP is split into two parts, the care component and the mobility component. It’s incredibly arduous to claim. You have to fill in pages and pages of forms. You have to endure a barrage of very personal questions in a face to face interview (or maybe by telephone) and then more often than not you wait weeks for a letter saying no, you can’t have anything. The next step is a mandatory reconsideration and finally a tribunal. Most sick people find the whole process too difficult and give up. There will always be some who know how to ‘play’ the system, but they would need very relaxed assessors and I’ve never actually met one. The evidence required for your disability is extensive and GPs are not allowed to intervene so it has to be hospital or other professionals (like psychiatrist or psychologist’s) notes.
They are proposing reviews for all claimants with only those who score 4 in one of the care components will be able to claim.
PIP was designed to give people independence, it’s non means tested which means you can work and claim PIP if it helps you to do your job. By limiting it to the most severely disabled kind of defeats that point.
I have bought many aids, mostly with my PIP and this means I can do the things on the list with little help, which means I wouldn’t actually score a 4. I can wash myself because I have an adapted wet room. I can use a microwave without help (the air fryer has been a godsend because it means I don’t have to bend down to cook in the oven,) but because of these I don’t score 4. I’m able to work out my finances and read a book, and hold a conversation. So I don’t score 4. I can keep my mobility benefit but what’s the point. There is no way I’ll be able to eat let alone put petrol in the car! I will not be able to buy any further aids like new walking sticks or a lot of other things I need which are a little more personal but all used with my PIP money to stop me from having to use my regular income. My regular income will be reduced because I don’t get PIP unless I actively seek work and apply for jobs! The car will have to go, and then I’ll be trapped at home even more and reliant on hospital transportation for my appointments. I can’t go anywhere without help and my helper left me.
I could write a whole new post on Motability cars, some people just don’t understand how the system works. The amount of abuse I’ve seen online from people who don’t understand how it works. In brief, the cars are not free, you have to pay an upfront free for most of them which can be anything from £250 to £4000 or more. You can have one adaptation, and further ones cost, and they cost a lot. You have to give up £75 a week of your benefit to pay for the car. The car is never really yours, you have to give it back after 3 years. To collect a car you need to prove that you are entitled to full mobility payments and car dealers cannot give you a car without a pin number from the DWP. You don’t need to be disabled to drive the car, you can nominate a driver. The car is for the use of the disabled person but can be used without them being in it. This is just a brief outline.
If you want to have your say you can write to your MP
You can fill in the open consultation here; It’s long but you don’t have to answer every question about all of the benefits.
You can sign many of the benefits petitions going around on SM. Or This one
Many people, including myself are very scared that some of these reforms will go ahead. The whole plan needs a complete rework. Benefit fraud on PIP last year was 0% so they really are trying to get money out of the most vulnerable people in this Country. Does that seem fair to you?

The government needs to realise that Covid had such a knock on effect to so many people’s lives!! We are still waiting for an appointment for my youngest and have been since 2022, they said she should be seen by the end of the year and the reason, they are still dealing with the backlog from Covid times. Her heart check appointment is a year late too. Ugh!
The mental health help is ridiculous on the NHS. I have found that unless you feel suicidal on the day that you get to see someone, they have no interest and don’t even get me started on CAMHS!
I know someone who has a lot of health problems including a non cancerous tumour on their brain which causes seizures, arthritis in their neck and back problems, they can hardly move some days and have had a stroke but they still have to look for work and have been refused PIP. No one will employ them due to the time they need off for hospital and doctor appointments and sick days that they have to take. They’ve now been told to find a work from home job which is easier said than done.
The whole system is wrong and just because you have found a way to live around your disability using aids and things like your wet room it seems so wrong that you would be penalised. I feel so scared for you and people with disabilities!
I don’t even know what to say! That sounds so frightening and downright cold-hearted to take away benefits. I’m really sorry this is happening to you and so many others.